Sunday, December 25, 2011

Rams' offense looks anemic against Steelers

By Jim Thomas
St. Louis Post-Dispatch
http://www.stltoday.com/sports/
December 25, 2011

PITTSBURGH, PA - DECEMBER 24: Linebackers Lawrence Timmons #94 and James Harrison #92 of the Pittsburgh Steelers sack quarterback Kellen Clemens #10 of the St. Louis Rams in the fourth quarter of their game at Heinz Field on December 24, 2011 in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. (Photo by Karl Walter/Getty Images)

PITTSBURGH • So here the Rams are again — another Christmas, another season near the bottom of the heap in the NFL. When they won seven games in 2010, and came within a victory of the NFC West title, there was an expectation that the worst was behind this forlorn franchise.

Steven Jackson admits he thought that was the case.

"I was hopeful," he said. "I must admit that I did."

But after a 27-0 loss to Pittsburgh, the Rams flew home Christmas Eve with a 2-13 record. For the fourth time in five years the Rams will finish a season with three victories or fewer.

There wasn't much suspense Saturday at Heinz Field. In a black-and-gold sea of Terrible Towels, the Rams lost their sixth game in row in almost stereotypical fashion.

The defense was willing. But the offense? Well, it would have trouble scoring in a singles bar. Victims of a shutout for the second time in four games, the Rams had their best scoring chances end in missed field goals of 52 and 33 yards by Josh Brown.

Defensively, the Rams allowed three big plays: a 35-yard reception by Rashard Mendenhall, a 52-yard run by Mendenhall and a 46-yard reception by Mike Wallace. None were scoring plays, but they led to two touchdowns and a field goal by the Steelers, who improved to 11-4.

Starting in place of Sam Bradford at quarterback, Kellen Clemens came down to earth after his surprisingly good Rams debut last weekend against Cincinnati. He completed a mere nine of 24 passes for 91 yards and a 49.1 passer rating against Pittsburgh's No. 1-ranked defense.

"In the spirit of Christmas, they weren't very giving," Clemens said. "Very stingy on defense, the Pittsburgh Steelers today. They're an elite defense."

The Rams' longest pass play of the day went for only 17 yards, with a 22-yarder to Brandon Lloyd on the opening drive successfully challenged by Steelers coach Mike Tomlin, changing the call to an incomplete pass.

"There's a few throws I just should've hit," Clemens said. "A couple other throws where we had an opportunity and didn't convert. You can't leave opportunities on the table against a defense like that. And we did today."

About the only bright spots for the Rams were Josh Gordy's third interception of the season — and second in as many games — and Jackson's 103 yards rushing. In the process, Jackson became just the seventh player in NFL history with seven or more consecutive seasons with 1,000 yards rushing.

"That's awesome," left guard Jason Brown said. —"'Jack' works his butt off, runs his butt off. He deserves it."

But the Rams reached the red zone only once and the result of that was Brown's missed 33-yarder. If Brown makes both field goals, it's 13-6 Steelers early in the fourth quarter. It's a one-score game and who knows.

"We're saying the same thing over there (on the sideline)," coach Steve Spagnuolo said. "But unfortunately that didn't happen. Let's face it. That's an elite defense, and the points are going to be few and far between. So when you get it in there and you can get at least three, that's what you need. If it's 13-6 and it's a one-possession game ... you're just one play away."

Instead it remained 13-0, and when Pittsburgh punched in two touchdowns in the final 9 minutes of the fourth quarter, it became a 27-0 rout. The Steelers did this without quarterback Ben Roethlisberger, who rested his high ankle sprain with the playoffs in mind.

"Obviously, he's less than 100 percent, and it's our desire at this juncture to get him as close to 100 percent as we can for January football," Tomlin told Steelers.com before the game. "I felt like this week provided an opportunity to do that."

That was a polite way of saying: "Even with Charlie Batch at quarterback, we should be able to take care of the Rams."

That's pretty much what happened. Batch threw only 22 passes, with the Steelers relying more on Mendenhall (18 carries, 116 yards) and the running game than usual.

"I thought they would try to run the ball more," Rams linebacker James Laurinaitis said. "I thought they would do a lot of counters, which they did. They're very similar to Arizona offensively, as far as what their run schemes are. Same coaching schemes."

That's because Arizona head coach Ken Whisenhunt came to the Cardinals from the Steelers.

Laurinaitis added: "That second game against Arizona, what hurt us was counters and stuff, and that's what (Pittsburgh) started doing. We stopped some of 'em; some of 'em we didn't."

So either the Rams just aren't good enough to play consistent run defense or they just don't learn from mistakes. As a team, the Steelers rushed for 169 yards. If the Rams give up 159 yards rushing in the Jan. 1 season finale against San Francisco, they will be the worst rushing defense in franchise history in terms of yards allowed.

The 2008 Rams of Scott Linehan and interim head coach Jim Haslett yielded a franchise worst 2,475 yards rushing; the 2011 Rams are at 2,317 yards after Saturday. But all things considered, the defense wasn't the problem. Once again, it kept the Rams in the game until the fourth quarter.

It's the offense, which is staggering through a season-closing stretch of facing six top 10 defenses over the final seven games of the season. With only the 49ers, and their fifth-ranked defense left to play, the Rams have been outscored 150-53 during the six-game losing streak.

"They schedule 'em; we gotta play 'em," Spagnuolo said. "It makes it tough for us, and yet our guys are still in there battling. And in the offensive line — we know all those issues there — it's been going on all year long. But I thought today they did a pretty nice job in helping Steven get those yards."

With zero points.

Saturday, December 24, 2011

Rams vs. Steelers: 7 things to watch

By Jim Thomas
The St. Louis Post-Dispatch
http://www.stltoday.com/sports/
December 24, 2011

SAN FRANCISCO, CA - DECEMBER 19: Quarterback #16 Charlie Batch of the Pittsburgh Steelers warms up before the game against the San Francisco 49ers at Candlestick Park on December 19, 2011 in San Francisco, California. (Photo by Karl Walter/Getty Images)

Battle of the backups

The hoped-for battle of the high ankle sprains has turned into the battle of the backups. Kellen Clemens is expected to start for the Rams in place of Sam Bradford, who's listed as doubtful because of his left ankle injury. Meanwhile, Charlie Batch was named Pittsburgh's starting QB in place of Ben Roethlisberger, who also has a left ankle injury. It was one thing to start a gimpy Roethlisberger last Monday in San Francisco with the No. 1 AFC playoff seed at stake. But why risk further damage against the 2-12 Rams?

Rush hour

With 774 yards rushing and just two games to go, Steelers RB Rashard Mendenhall needs to finish strong to reach 1,000 yards for the third consecutive season. So he'll be happy to see the Rams, who rank last in the league in rushing defense, as they yield 153.4 yards per game. Mendenhall's numbers are down, but the Steelers simply are tied more to the passing game this season. The Illinois product is averaging 13 carries a game this season as opposed to 20 carries per game in 2010, when he gained 1,273 yards.

Long vs. Gilbert

Rams DE Chris Long gets a rookie in Steelers RT Marcus Gilbert, but a good rookie at that. Gilbert (6-6, 330) stepped into the starting lineup after Willie Colon suffered a season-ending triceps injury on opening day. Gilbert has played well, so well there's speculation he might be switched to left tackle next season. Gilbert didn't exactly shower Long with praise when asked about the matchup: "He's no Aldon Smith, but he's a high-motor guy," Gilbert told the Beaver County (pA.) Times. Long has a career-high 13 sacks.

Harrison & Woodley

Few if any 3-4 teams have the kind of thunder at outside linebacker as the Steelers do in James Harrison and LaMarr Woodley. Even though they've missed nine games between them, they've combined for 17 sacks. Woodley might not play because of a hamstring injury, but Harrison is rested and ready after serving a one-game suspension for a flagrant hit on Browns QB Colt McCoy. Harrison will be an ultra-tough matchup for LT Adam Goldberg. "He's a violent pass rusher," Rams offensive coordinator Josh McDaniels said.

Where's Troy?

With apologies to Harrison and Woodley, the heart and soul of Pittsburgh's No. 1-ranked defense remains safety Troy Polamalu, who's talented, fast and has a great mind for the game. "He can be anywhere," McDaniels said. "Sometimes he's back in the deep part of the field, where you feel safer. And other times you gotta find him." Polamalu does some free-lancing, and it's hard to tell sometimes if he's blitzing — or just coming on his own. "He's never wrong, which is the problem," McDaniels said.

The Danario saga

Mizzou product Danario Alexander made a difference in three Rams victories last season with key catches. But he struggled in camp this summer, barely made the team, and after a decent start missed five games because of a hamstring injury. He resurfaced last Sunday with 3 catches for 52 yards against Cincinnati, including a 25-yard TD. With Austin Pettis suspended, Alexander should see plenty of action in the final two games. It's a chance to remind this coaching staff — or the next — he's worth keeping.

Memory lane

The Rams have played in Pittsburgh only twice previously since the move to St. Louis, and both games were memorable. Traded to Pittsburgh during the '96 draft, Jerome Bettis got revenge on his old team less than seven months later rushing for 129 yards and 2 TDs in a 42-6 Steelers romp. In 2003, with Marshall Faulk and Lamar Gordon out because of injuries, third-stringer Arlen Harris rushed for 81 yards on 34 carries, scoring 3 TDs in a 33-21 Rams victory. Harris scored only 3 other TDs in a four-year NFL career.

Highlights: Penguins 4, Jets 1

Friday, December 23, 2011

Ziggy Hood makes a mark with Steelers

BY KATHLEEN NELSON • knelson@post-dispatch.com > 314-340-8233
http://www.stltoday.com/sports/
December 23, 2011

PITTSBURGH, PA - NOVEMBER 6: Ziggy Hood(notes) #96 of the Pittsburgh Steelers pumps up the crowd against the Baltimore Ravens during the game on November 6, 2011 at Heinz Field in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. (Photo by Justin K. Aller/Getty Images)

With 10 days between their victory on Dec. 8 over Cleveland and their loss Monday to San Francisco, the Pittsburgh Steelers found time to create holiday greetings for their fans.

Each unit — the linebackers, the offensive line, the defensive backs, etc. — prepared a video rendition of a traditional carol. The collection is available for viewing at steelers.com.

"You don't have to worry about them quitting their day jobs," Steelers coach Mike Tomlin said between chuckles.

None of the groups approaches the zeal with which the defensive line belts out "Winter Wonderland." And no one gives it more oomph than Ziggy Hood, former Missouri Tigers defensive tackle turned NFL defensive end. Hood manages to mouth about every other word, but can really bust a Christmas move.

"That was a good time," Hood said. "I didn't know all the words, and I'm not going to lie. I thought I'd bring more entertainment with my dancing. The big guys are always fun to be round, so that's why we're the best."

After almost three seasons, Hood seems to have found his place with the Steelers, though he seemed destined to become a fun guy since childhood. Christened Evander Hood in Amarillo, Texas, in 1987, he has been known since he was toddler as "Ziggy," a nickname given to him by his cartoon-loving grandmother.

Hood is one of a trio of former Missouri defensive lineman drafted in the first round who have earned starting jobs in the NFL; the others are Justin and Aldon Smith of the 49ers.

Hood gave credit to defensive line coach Craig Kuligowski for his development.

"I just think that it comes from all the coaching up there," Hood said. "And then I think he's got a couple more guys coming out in this year's draft. I just think it goes back to who they're recruiting and what they're doing up there. They're giving the guys the opportunity to showcase themselves on TV."

A defensive tackle with the Tigers, Hood had his most productive year in 2007, his junior season, with 49 tackles, five sacks and three forced fumbles. His statistics dropped his senior season, when opposing offenses keyed on him and he finished with 23 tackles, 2.5 tackles for loss and 1.5 sacks. His stock rose considerably, though, at the NFL combine and at Missouri's pro day before the 2009 draft.

"His motor was attractive, a guy that plays hard," Tomlin said. "He had a nice skill set or pedigree, as we like to call it, but probably the most interesting thing was just his overall work ethic and approach to football, not only in terms of what we were able to see on tape, but the words that were spoken about him by teammates and coaches and people at the University of Missouri."

Thus, the Steelers took Hood with the final pick of the first round, 32nd overall, with the notion of converting him to a defensive end in their 3-4 scheme.

"I think my technique has gotten 10 times better," Hood said. "You can see a dramatic change from my first year to now to where I can handle double teams or shedding blockers or getting back to the QB, all of the little things that make a 3-4 defensive end. I think I'm starting to come through at that end."

Hood played in all 16 games as a rookie and started nine games last year, earning three sacks and 20 tackles. He has started 12 of 14 games this season, with 25 tackles. "Measureables" aren't the hallmark of the Steelers defensive line, though.

Instead, Hood said, he had to learn about "engaging in blockers and holding them at the point of attack and really not letting myself get too carried off like I've got to be the guy that makes the play. I've got to understand this defense is made for linebackers, and I've got to understand that if I hold this gap or hold this point of attack and my linebackers come through then that's a plus for everybody. If I try to do too much or try to be selfish, that hurts the team."

Almost three years into his pro career, Hood seems to have embraced the Steelers' philosophy and Pittsburgh as home.

"I own about three Terrible Towels,'' he said. "I own a pink one, a black one and an original yellow one that they have. They're just special to me for what I have in my man cave.

"It's been a fun ride, and I'm blessed to have this opportunity to play with this group of guys and to work under these coaches. It's just been amazing for what they have done for me and what all I can do for them when it comes, playing game-wise and stuff like that. It's just been a very positive vibe for them."

Thursday, December 22, 2011

Is Saturday the last home hurrah for Hines Ward?

By Mike Bires
mbires@timesonline.com
Beaver County Times
http://www.timesonline.com/sports/
December 22, 2011

Pittsburgh Steelers receivers Hines Ward and Mike Wallace sit on the bench during the second quarter of an NFL football game against the Cincinnati Bengals in Pittsburgh, Sunday, Dec 4, 2011. (AP)

PITTSBURGH -- These are trying times for Hines Ward. That's easy to tell. He's just not flashing his trademark smile as often as he's done so many times over the years.

He may be the franchise's all-time receptions leader. He may be a future Hall of Famer. But as he gets closer to his 36th birthday, he's clearly being phased out of the Steelers' offense.

So the question begs to be asked: Might Saturday's game against the St. Louis Rams mark the last time Ward plays at Heinz Field?

"It's hard to even think about," quarterback Ben Roethlisberger said. "It's not like we go, 'Hines, is this your last year?'

"We don't know. I don't think he knows. Nobody knows. Obviously, we all know there's a chance it could be. It's tough to think about, and it's tough to talk about it. We really don't know how to feel about it yet."

The Christmas Eve game against the Rams could be the Steelers' last home game this season -- if they don't overtake the Ravens and win the AFC North. The Steelers have already clinched at least a wild-card berth, and if they remain a wild card, they'll open the playoffs on the road and figure to stay on the road unless the top four seeds lose.

Ward, who holds 13 team pass receiving records, is under contract through the 2013 season. But would he want to return next year as the fourth or fifth receiver in the rotation? Would the organization want him back in that role?

And if Ward does return next year, he would probably have to take a hefty pay cut. After all, he's due to make $4 million in base salary in 2012.

"No, I don't even think like that," Ward said when asked about Saturday possibly being his last home game in Pittsburgh. "Every year is different. I'm just glad to still be here. That thought hasn't even crossed my mind."

Ward, who turns 36 in March, began his 14th season as a starter. But in the Nov. 13 game in Cincinnati, he lost his starting job to emerging star Antonio Brown.

Along with third-year pro Mike Wallace, Brown and Emmanuel Sanders, who were both selected in last year's draft, give the Steelers a trio of young, fast and talented receivers. They're the Steelers' future at wideout.

In recent weeks, Ward has even dropped down in the pecking order behind eighth-year pro Jerricho Cotchery, who joined the Steelers in August.

In the past two games, the Steelers have thrown 67 passes. Only one was thrown to Ward. He had one catch on Dec. 8 against Cleveland but none Monday night in an Francisco.

"Anything is possible," Wallace said when asked if he thinks Ward will be back next year. "Hines has never said anything about it. No once. He just continues to show up and prepare for the next game."

When this season started, Ward needed 46 catches to become just the eighth receiver in NFL history to reach 1,000 in his career. With two games left, Ward has just 37 catches for 325 yards and just two touchdowns. He's on pace to have his worst season production-wise since he was a rookie in 1998.

And he still needs nine more receptions for the milestone.

"I'm on the cusp on 1,000, but I just want to win," he said. "The catches ... it really doesn't matter. We still have a chance to win the division. And it's always great to have a chance to win at home, especially this week with the game on Christmas Eve. This is special time of the year."

Veteran linebacker James Farrior hopes that if Saturday's game is indeed Ward's last in Pittsburgh, it will be special for the last guy who will ever wear No. 86 as a Steeler.

"To tell you the truth, we haven't really talked about it," Farrior said. "I don't know what Hines is thinking. But if this is going to be his last home game, we're going to send him out with a bang.

"He's got nine more catches to go (to reach 1,000). We've been counting them down with him all season. We've all been enjoying it. Hopefully, we can make it happen."

Wednesday, December 21, 2011

Poor effort with much on the line

Wednesday, December 21, 2011
By Ron Cook, Pittsburgh Post-Gazette
http://www.post-gazette.com/sports/

SAN FRANCISCO, CA - DECEMBER 19: Ben Roethlisberger #7 of the Pittsburgh Steelers is sacked by Aldon Smith #99 of the San Francisco 49ers at Candlestick Park on December 19, 2011 in San Francisco, California. (Photo by Ezra Shaw/Getty Images)

As he and his Steelers teammates sat in virtual blackness in their locker room in the massive toxic dump that is San Francisco's Candlestick Park in those tense moments Monday night before a big game, quarterback Ben Roethlisberger said he kept thinking the same thought.

How does this happen in a professional stadium?

Funny, isn't it?

A lot of us had a similar question after watching Roethlisberger and the Steelers play poorly from start to finish and literally stumble to a punishing 20-3 loss to the 49ers.

How does this happen to a professional football team when its season is on the line in so many ways?

Explaining the stadium blackout -- two, actually -- is easy. Candlestick was a hideous place when Joe Montana was throwing touchdown passes to Jerry Rice. Today, it's nothing less than an enormous embarrassment to the NFL.

But explaining the Steelers' lousy effort is much more difficult. They lost so much more than just a game. It's not as if their season is finished; they qualified for the playoffs Sunday with fortuitous losses by other would-be playoff teams. But they were playing for first place in the AFC North Division and the No. 1 seed for the conference playoffs and all of the wonderful benefits that go with each accomplishment. They got big breaks Sunday when the Baltimore Ravens and the Houston Texans lost.

At the risk of two gross oversimplifications and fully realizing two weeks remain in the regular season:

• Beat the 49ers, go to the Super Bowl.

• Lose to the 49ers, forget about the Super Bowl.

Other than that, it wasn't that big of a game.

"We've done it on the road before," Steelers nose tackle Casey Hampton insisted afterward. He was talking about the team's march to Super Bowl XL after the 2005 season. It won playoff games at Cincinnati, Indianapolis and Denver to get there, the first time a team had taken such an arduous path to the ultimate game.

But that was then.

This is now.

These Steelers are very good at home, their 6-1 record the proof. They beat the New England Patriots at Heinz Field with relative ease. Their only loss was to the Ravens, who had to go 92 yards in the final 2 1/2 minutes to beat them. They are averaging 24.7 points at home and giving up 11.4. Roethlisberger has thrown 14 touchdown passes and four interceptions at home and been sacked 15 times. His passer rating is 107.1 at home.

It's easy to make a case for the Steelers going to their fourth Super Bowl in seven years if they win their division and get the No. 1 or even the No. 2 seed in the AFC playoffs.

But these Steelers are ordinary -- at best -- on the road, their 4-3 record the proof. They lost to the three playoff-bound teams they faced on the road -- Baltimore, Houston and San Francisco -- and really weren't in those games. They barely beat lightweights Indianapolis and Kansas City on the road. They are averaging 16 points in away games and giving up 19.7. Roethlisberger has thrown seven touchdown passes and 10 interceptions on the road and been sacked 23 times. His passer rating is 78.2 on the road.

It's almost impossible to imagine the Steelers making it to the Super Bowl as a road playoff team.

Let's go back to Hampton, not just on the loss to the 49ers but on the difficult challenge facing the Steelers. To win the AFC North and get at least one home playoff game, they must beat the St. Louis Rams Saturday at Heinz Field and the Cleveland Browns Jan. 1 on the road. They also must hope the Ravens lose at home Saturday to the Browns or at Cincinnati in the final game.

"Everything we did, we did it to ourselves," Hampton said. "We can't cry about it."

It's easy to blame Roethlisberger's bad ankle for the loss to the 49ers. Clearly, his mobility was limited. He threw three interceptions, lost a fumble and finished with a passer rating of 52.3, his worst of the season. He was sacked three times.

"We were moving the ball," coach Mike Tomlin said. "We just weren't finishing drives. We were turning the ball over."

Who am I to argue?

Tomlin made it clear he didn't think Roethlisberger's ankle was a factor in the loss. He said he had no second thoughts about starting him and never considered taking him out during the game. He did acknowledge you might disagree with one or both of those decisions.

"We don't live in our fears," Tomlin said. "We live in our hopes ... We won't apologize for it."

I have no problem with that thinking.

I like it and respect it, actually.

This loss wasn't just about Roethlisberger, his ankle and the offense's worst point production of the season. "It was a losing performance by us," Tomlin said. "We just didn't play very well."

The Steelers defense wasn't even close to as effective as the 49ers defense; it didn't get a sack or force a turnover. "If we want to be a great defense, we've got to do better than that," linebacker LaMarr Woodley said.

The special teams were outplayed by the 49ers special teams. Punter Andy Lee -- a former Pitt player -- did his job better than anyone on the field, finishing with a silly-good 49.2-yard net average on six kicks and forcing the Steelers to start their drives, on average, at their 15. "We were working on long fields," Tomlin said.

All of it made for a very long night.

"We came to the West Coast and we got our butts whipped," safety Ryan Clark said.

Here's the worst part:

The sting from that whipping figures to last for a long time if the Steelers don't get to play home football in January.

Highlights: Penguins 3, Blackhawks 2

Tuesday, December 20, 2011

Steelers stumble, fumble in dark

By Dejan Kovacevic, PITTSBURGH TRIBUNE-REVIEW
http://www.pittsburghlive.com/x/pittsburghtrib/sports/
Tuesday, December 20, 2011

SAN FRANCISCO, CA - DECEMBER 19: Ben Roethlisberger #7 of the Pittsburgh Steelers fumbles the ball after being sacked by Aldon Smith #99 and Justin Smith #94 of the San Francisco 49ers at Candlestick Park on December 19, 2011 in San Francisco, California. Smith recovered the fumble for the 49ers. (Photo by Ezra Shaw/Getty Images)

SAN FRANCISCO — The drama was thick Monday night at Candlestick Park, and this was well before the paying customers realized they'd need to light their own candles to take in the craziness to come.

Grab a match. Here we go ...

It's 6:15 p.m. Pittsburgh time, and Ben Roethlisberger's every step in early warmups is scrutinized to monitor the planet's most prominent high left ankle sprain. It's soon as painful to watch as it appears to execute. Roethlisberger makes like a marble statue as he tosses 7-yard softies with a couple of the Steelers' coaches. He redefines stiffness in trying three-step drops. And he cringes as he's ushered off, just four minutes after he began.

Yep, he's ready to go, coach. This one's going to be all on you, Mike Tomlin, for better or worse.

At 7 p.m., the Steelers' inactive list omits Roethlisberger, and the Nation emits a sigh. Never mind that being inactive is the only cure for the dreaded high ankle sprain. Never mind that, even if the ankle holds up, he'll be a stationary target for an aggressive San Francisco defense. This game is all that matters, apparently, to Tomlin and all concerned.

At 8:30 p.m., 10 minutes before kickoff, the stadium blacks out, representing the catastrophe of the century. At least it sounds that way to those tuning in ESPN's Chris Berman hyperbolically comparing a blown transformer to the 1989 World Series earthquake here that, you know, collapsed the Bay Bridge.

At 9 p.m., with the lights back, the cosmos settled and kickoff delayed a mere 20 minutes, Roethlisberger looks cool but cautious in moving the ball quickly, much the same approach adopted for the ankle-impaired Tennessee victory two months ago.

At 9:12 p.m., Roethlisberger plants poorly and underthrows even worse into the end zone for an interception.

At 9:23 p.m., another interception, this one overthrown.

At 9:43 p.m., as if by merciful intervention, the stadium blacks out a second time. Although Berman presumably is under a table somewhere, the fans have fun with it, flash bulbs popping everywhere. What had been a fine NFL matchup of 10-3 teams is now a freak show.

At 9:48 p.m., just as it was becoming moderately reasonable to accuse the 49ers of trying to fortify the case for a new stadium in nearby Santa Clara, a fan runs onto the field. The police somehow put him down quickly, though not before Roethlisberger is overheard joking, "Where's James Harrison when you need him?"

At 9:50 p.m., Harrison is exactly where Roger Goodell wants him, back on his couch in Pittsburgh, having a good laugh: "If I can't play then can't nobody play," he tweets. "Lights out!"

At 9:52 p.m., in a remarkable coincidence, the ESPN broadcast shows an artist's rendering of the dreamy new stadium in Santa Clara. Complete with transformers that don't explode into flames.

At 9:58 p.m., the lights are back again. Some, anyway. One bank, right at midfield, has only seven of its 60 bulbs turned on.

At 10:33 p.m., the Steelers stall out on a late drive and trail, 6-0, even as Roethlisberger begins to act more like himself, holding the ball, squirting away from rushers and looking deep for Mike Wallace and Antonio Brown.

At 11:10 p.m., Roethlisberger finds his stride, moving fluidly before finding Heath Miller with a pump-fake and a strike for 39 yards to midfield. No more limp, no more condensed playbook.

At 11:17 p.m., alas, this drive falls short, too, as Roethlisberger's back-shoulder pass to Brown is askew enough to force the Steelers to settle for a field goal.

At 11:27 p.m., the 49ers finally find the end zone after making the Steelers' defense look terribly ordinary. Might be a fact of life anymore, injuries or otherwise.

At 11:44 p.m., speaking of injuries, LaMarr Woodley exits again because of his hamstring. For all the fuss over whether the Steelers should play Roethlisberger, why so little over a guy who was on a player-of-the-year course before getting hurt?

At 11:48 p.m., Roethlisberger is pile-driven by Aldon Smith, the fumble is recovered by Justin Smith, and Roethlisberger's linemen peel him slowly off the grass.

At 11:55 p.m., sacked again.

At 12:08 a.m., sacked again.

At 12:11 a.m., intercepted again.

At 12:14 a.m., Charlie Batch warms up.

At 12:20 a.m., Roethlisberger goes back out, anyway, and winds up 25 of 44 for 330 yards in the air, which would be fine except for those four turnovers and the lowest output of his illustrious career.

At 12:26 a.m., the scoreboard lights up — against all technological odds — the final: 49ers 20, Steelers 3.

At 12:41 a.m., Tomlin explains his decision to stick by Roethlisberger: "He was deemed healthy enough to play. We always like what Ben provides us. We appreciate his efforts. Obviously, we fell short."

At 1:04 a.m., Roethlisberger divulges that he balked against Batch entering late because, as he put it, "I didn't want to quit on my teammates."

But he could talk the coach out of a call that important?

At 1:06 a.m., John Norwig, the Steelers' head athletic trainer, barks at Steve Young of the ESPN crew, who had been critical of the Steelers' decision to use Roethlisberger and predicted they'd need to administer cortisone: "He played without a needle," Norwig tells Young.

Really, could all this have been any messier with Batch behind center?


SAN FRANCISCO, CA - DECEMBER 19: Vernon Davis #85 of the San Francisco 49ers is pushed out of bounds at the one yard line by Lawrence Timmons #94 of the Pittsburgh Steelers at Candlestick Park on December 19, 2011 in San Francisco, California. The 49ers won the game 20-3. (Photo by Thearon W. Henderson/Getty Images)

Game balls

Columnist Dejan Kovacevic selects the game's top performers:

Aldon Smith, 49ers, LB — Ben Roethlisberger's worst enemy with seven quarterback hits, 2.5 sacks, two tackles for losses and a forced fumble.

Vernon Davis, 49ers, TE — Caught six balls for 72 yards and the easiest touchdown anyone's produced in the NFL all season

Jerricho Cotchery, Steelers, WR — Five catches for a game-high 93 yards would signify he's going to be taking a lot more of Hines Ward's playing time

Turn Out The Lights - The Party's Just Starting

By Scott Ostler
San Francisco Chronicle
http://www.sfgate.com/sports/
Tuesday, December 20, 2011

SAN FRANCISCO, CA - DECEMBER 19: The power goes for a second time causing a 16-minute delay before play is resumed at the 12:13 mark in the second quarter between the Pittsburgh Steelers and the San Francisco 49ers at Candlestick Park on December 19, 2011 in San Francisco, California. (Photo by Ezra Shaw/Getty Images)

Ah, San Francisco - the only NFL city that has stadium mood lighting.

Romantic table for 69,732? Right this way.

Unfortunately, the fans who came to the Steelers-49ers game Monday night didn't get the PG&E memo asking each fan to bring a candlestick to Candlestick.

There was little or no panic in the stands when the lights went out twice, probably because about half the people in the seats were Pennsylvania coal miners, accustomed to pitch-black working conditions.

On the field, nobody was happy. The Steelers suspected foul play, maybe Jim Harbaugh gamesmanship. You can't trust Harbaugh's handshakes, why trust him with the light switches?

The 49ers were ticked off because the two long delays gave Steelers quarterback Ben Roethlisberger time to heal his sprained ankle.

Meanwhile, south of the 'Stick, the folks planning to build the 49ers a stadium rushed to update their website with a new slogan: "Santa Clara: We've got lektricity!"

Not that clever, but better than San Francisco's new motto: "We're half-lit."

And this is so San Francisco: During the first blackout, somebody spotted Reddi Kilowatt under the bleachers, smoking a doobie.

When word went out that the problem was a balky transformer, the news got twisted on the Internet, leaving folks back in Pittsburgh and around the country asking, "Is that the San Francisco thing where you can't decide which way to dress?"

Hey, it was a goofy night, but this is a season for the unpredictable and unexpected for the 49ers.

At the beginning of the season (we now move to football talk), who would have predicted that at Week 15, 49ers quarterback Alex Smith would be on the team, let alone that he would outplay Roethlisberger?

Sure, Roethlisberger was injured, playing on a badly sprained ankle that left him as mobile as a peg-legged pirate captain. Still.

Incidentally, why was Roethlisberger even in the game? The Steelers are fighting for favorable playoff position, but Roethlisberger was a glacier.

Throwing off one foot, Roethlisberger threw two interceptions in the first quarter. And his signature, extending the play by buying time by ducking and weaving and knocking people over, was null and void.

Even in the fourth quarter, the Steelers in a no-chance situation, Roethlisberger played. For whom? For what?

Smith, meanwhile, continues to be the most fascinating quarterback in the NFL, with all due respect to Tim Tebow. Much of football is entranced by the theater of Tebow, but is convinced he is a passing (or non-passing) fad.

Smith exists in the real NFL world, and he's the most unexplainable quarterback on a contending team. With him, the question persists: Can the 49ers finish strong and continue to perform with a quarterback who has improved more than any QB in the league, but so often seems a cut below the big guys, the Roethlisbergers, Rodgerses, Bradys, Breeses and their elite ilk?

There's no doubt in Jim Harbaugh's mind.

"Tremendous job by Alex Smith," the 49ers' head coach said. "He was just on the money all night long. Played great. There's no doubt in my mind that he deserves to go to the Pro Bowl. He's had that kind of season, and he really put an exclamation point on that tonight."

Spectacular? No.

Really good, and efficient. Check.

Appropriately, Smith's civvies Monday night included his Harbaugh-issued blue-collar gas-station-attendant shirt with "Alex" on one pocket. And his S.F. Giants ballcap.

Against the best pass defense in the league, Smith was 18-for-31 for 187 yards, one touchdown, zero interceptions and zero sacks - after taking 18 sacks the previous three games.

Harbaugh, showing faith in Smith, didn't shy away from the pass against the hawkish Steelers. Five of the first eight plays were passes.

Along with the efficiency, Smith had flashes of hotness - not to be confused with hot flashes. Such as the 49ers' first touchdown drive in the third quarter. He faked the Pittsburgh defenders out of their jocks on back-to-back plays - a 21-yard, cross-field, over-the-shoulder loft to Vernon Davis, then a play-action flip to Davis alone in the end zone.

Yes, Davis was back in the thick of the offense: six catches for 72 yards.

"Feels good to be back in the passing game," Davis said.

The touchdown pass was a nice red-zone moment for the 49ers, who, to that point, had scored touchdowns on only three of their previous 20 trips to the red zone. Red zone? For the 49ers, it has been more like the Bermuda Rectangle.

Big night for Smith, big win for 49ers. Turn out the lights, the party's just starting.

E-mail Scott Ostler at sostler@sfchronicle.com.

Monday, December 19, 2011

Healing hockey's headache

By Mark Madden
Beaver County Times
http://www.timesonline.com/sports/
December 18, 2011

MONTREAL, CANADA - NOVEMBER 26: Kris Letang(notes) #58 of the Pittsburgh Penguins is tended to by Pittsburgh Penguins staff after being hit by Max Pacioretty(notes) #67 of the Montreal Canadiens (not pictured) during the NHL game at the Bell Centre on November 26, 2011 in Montreal, Quebec, Canada. The Penguins defeated the Canadiens 4-3 in overtime. (Photo by Richard Wolowicz/Getty Images)

Right now, hockey is a war of attrition. That's just a phrase, something you might hear on SportsCenter. It's not supposed to be taken literally, let alone true.

But the following NHL players are currently sidelined with concussions:

* The Penguins' Sidney Crosby, the league's best player.

* Philadelphia's Claude Giroux, tied for the scoring lead before last night's action.

* Ottawa's Milan Michalek, until recently the league's top goal-scorer.

* Carolina's Jeff Skinner, last season's Calder Trophy winner as best rookie.

* The Penguins' Kris Letang, the NHL's premier young defenseman.

Injuries are part of hockey. But they shouldn't ruin hockey.

Perhaps most depressing about hockey's concussion epidemic is that no moves are being made to halt it. Treatment is better. Technology has improved. Caution is omnipresent.

But what should the NHL do to solve the problem? To cut down on concussions? To be proactive?

Here are three things, to start:

* Adopt no-touch icing. That eliminates a ton of mindless collisions.

* Ban all head shots. Don't judge case-by-case. Ditch the gray area.

* Ban fighting. Bare-knuckled punches to the head have nothing to do with hockey.

The NHL could adopt all three measures immediately and it would not change the way hockey is played one bit.

Would concussions be eliminated? Hardly. But you'd lessen the chances.

Don't hold your breath. Bill Masterson of the Minnesota North Stars died in 1968 when he smashed his bare head on the ice after being checked. The NHL didn't make helmets mandatory until 1979. Even then, veterans who had played without helmets could finish their careers without donning one. One dead guy? No big deal. Concussed superstars? Ditto.

The NHL is watching marketable assets drop like flies, but doing nothing to stem the tide. Medical advancement helps after the fact. But to prevent concussions -- to keep the Crosbys, Girouxs and Skinners on the ice -- you need to change the game.

Shoulder and elbow pads are hard as steel and can be used as weapons. Hear anybody discussing adjustments? No.

Helmet technology could be improved. Add more padding, or outside padding. Make full face cages mandatory. Hear anybody talking about that? No.

The NHL wants tough to equal skill. Always. Changes aren't forthcoming. Concuss to your heart's content.

No-touch icing should be a no-brainer. Blow the whistle when the puck crosses the goal line. How often does that race for the puck produce anything memorable or positive?

Until you discipline all head shots, players won't try to avoid them. That's the key, creating a culture of avoidance. If there's a gray area, players believe they might beat the rap.

The New York Times published a series of articles on the late NHL enforcer Derek Boogaard earlier this month. The revelations contained therein should be enough to get rid of fighting. Boogaard's brain was literally beaten senseless. The NHL rule allowing fighting has been around since 1917. That defines antiquated.

These changes, hopefully, would take a bite out of concussions. If not, hockey might have to go further: Bigger rinks. Playing four-on-four all the time. One-stride checking instead of two. Minimizing or eliminating contact in certain areas of the ice.

Those changes are drastic. No-touch icing, banning head shots, banning fighting -- those are not. They're simple. Easy to apply. The NHL has to start somewhere.

But the NHL won't start anywhere. The NHL won't change. The league pays lip service to the welfare of its players, but it doesn't care. Be tough. That's what matters.

The Stanley Cup champion won't be the best team. It will be the team that gets luckiest with injuries. Excuse me if I don't watch. My brain hurts.


Mark Madden hosts a radio show 3-6 p.m. weekdays on WXDX-FM (105.9).

Highlights: Penguins 8, Sabres 3

Wednesday, December 14, 2011

Harrison won't have last laugh

By Dejan Kovacevic, PITTSBURGH TRIBUNE-REVIEW
http://www.pittsburghlive.com/x/pittsburghtrib/sports/?_s_icmp=nav_sports
Wednesday, December 14, 2011

Colt McCoy was briefly removed from Thursday night's game after a helmet-to-helmet hit with Pittsburgh's James Harrison. (Charles LeClaire/US Presswire)

For all the gnashing of teeth that followed James Harrison's one-game NFL suspension Tuesday, the one issue I couldn't recall being raised on Twitter, talk shows or anywhere else was the most relevant: What about Harrison's next hit?

Seemed everyone wanted to do a Zapruder-like breakdown of Harrison's helmet-to-helmet missile strike that concussed Cleveland quarterback Colt McCoy last week. Or they wanted to review every similar hit over the past decade, then tally up the misdeeds.

Oh, the injustice of it all, the Nation cried in virtual unison.

A few of Harrison's teammates piped up, too, with cornerback Ike Taylor saying: "I don't understand how you punish James for playing through the whistle. He didn't punch anybody in the privates. He didn't stomp on anybody. He didn't spit in anyone's face. You're going to suspend a man for playing football."

Some of it makes for worthy debate.

Thing is, the past isn't the issue here. It's the future.

Let's assume the NFL harbors no ill will toward the Steelers (I've never bought that, given the Rooneys' stature) or toward Harrison (not so sure there, given that Roger Goodell has been known to read Men's Journal). That would make the league's motivation, in theory, an honorable one: Reduce concussions.

Well, Harrison's hit on McCoy was, as the league subtly pointed out in the headline of its press release, his "FIFTH ILLEGAL HIT AGAINST A QUARTERBACK IN THREE SEASONS." The suspension was intended to be cumulative. Moreover, both of the rules cited in the release — one regarding a passer out of the pocket still receiving "special protections," the other regarding "hits to a passer's head and use of the helmet" — were violated.

Case closed. That was easy.

So, do you fine Harrison?

How much of a fine is an effective deterrent to a player whose contract is worth $51 million and who shrugged off $100,000 in fines last year?

I had thought until the announcement that the league would go with a fine, and for no small reason: No player had ever been suspended for a head hit between the whistles. But the league evidently saw Harrison as being beyond fines, so they went with the one avenue they knew would get his — and everyone's — attention: They took him off the field.

It was the right move if aimed at discouraging Harrison in the future. You'd have to think that being forced to watch his teammates play Monday night in San Francisco — a pretty big game against the 49ers, you might have heard — will sting far more than the $73,529 he'll forfeit. He'll be letting the whole team down.

But really, I'm not sure any message will get through.

Remember, Harrison was telling reporters Monday that he expected neither a suspension nor a fine. That was either him trying to spin things or being outright delusional.

Then, Harrison's initial reaction to the suspension on his Twitter account was "LOL!!!" That's Internet code for "laugh out loud."

Imagine the reaction if he'd merely been fined.

It might be instructive for the Steelers and Harrison to look at the case of the Penguins' Matt Cooke.

When Cooke was issued his 17-game NHL suspension last season, it was unprecedented but widely viewed as fair, even locally. He'd been running players for years, and no piecemeal punishment had any effect until this one. He sat out the playoffs and watched his team rubbed out in the first round. Worse, he heard everyone inside the organization, from Mario Lemieux on down, challenge him to get his act together or get lost.

Since then, Cooke has changed his style, has kept clean and has been a terrific third-line player for the Penguins.

"The way I saw it, I had no choice," Cooke told me Tuesday. "I knew there was going to be extra attention on me, and I'm sure it's the same way with James. You can't slip up."

Lesson learned all around.

The NFL was fair to take this step with Harrison, but only for now. That can't be fully judged until there are more suspensions like it.

The Steelers have been fair, too. Tuesday, Mike Tomlin sharply dismissed any paranoia about the league being out to get Harrison and said of the suspension: "We'll accept that. We're disappointed for James. He's worked extremely hard to change his game."

It might not feel fair to Harrison, who is appealing the suspension through his agent — without the team's blessing, perhaps? — and told longtime friend Jerome Bettis on Tuesday he has no plan to change anything about the way he plays.

This is one head-on collision Harrison can't win.

Highlights: Red Wings 4, Penguins 1

Tuesday, December 13, 2011

Crosby is worth the wait

By Ron Cook, Pittsburgh Post-Gazette
http://www.post-gazette.com/sports/
December 13, 2011

Pittsburgh Penguins' Sidney Crosby(notes) collides with Boston Bruins' David Krejci(notes) (46) along the boards in the first period of an NHL hockey game, Monday, Dec. 5, 2011, in Pittsburgh. (AP)

Public sentiment appears to be turning against Penguins star Sidney Crosby, slowly but surely. Those who are preaching patience as he battles concussion-like symptoms for a second time this year remain the overwhelming majority. But more and more people are wondering if Crosby will be the same player again, which is to say the best in the world. They're wondering if he will survive for the long haul in the brutally physical NHL game. They are comparing him to Eric Lindros and Pat LaFontaine, players who were forced to retire prematurely because of concussions.

Some are more extreme.

A few -- I'll call them the lunatic fringe -- are saying the Penguins should look into trading him before the rest of the hockey world discovers he's soft.

Please.

Leave the nonsensical "Cindy" Crosby stuff to the moronic hockey fans in Philadelphia.

You are better than that here.

Patience is the only way to go with Crosby. He has more at stake than just hockey. He's 24 with a long life ahead. Concussions, as we are learning more and more each day, are nothing to minimize. Clearly, he shouldn't play again until he's ready.

But being patient can be difficult. I won't argue that. It was difficult when Crosby took hits to the head in games Jan. 1 and Jan. 5, then missed the final 41 regular-season games of the 2010-11 season, the seven-game first-round playoff series against the Tampa Bay Lightning and the first 20 games of this season. It's going to be especially difficult now that he lasted just eight games after making a spectacular comeback Nov. 21 against the New York Islanders.

Crosby confirmed the bad news Monday, announcing that he's again dealing with concussion-like symptoms, perhaps from a hit from Boston's David Krejci Dec. 5 that didn't appear to be all that ferocious. He said he didn't feel right the next day, reported a slight headache after practicing the day after that and said he has done only "light [exertion] stuff" since.

"There's no timetable" for a return, Crosby said.

And the days ahead?

"Kind of that whole routine again," Crosby said of the agonizing, one-step-at-a-time process that led to his first comeback.

"But hopefully not as long."

Are you thinking what I'm thinking? That it's pointless to speculate when Crosby will play again? Certainly, no one connected with the Penguins will do it. Not after coach Dan Bylsma talked of him having a "minor" concussion in January and making the prediction he would be back in a week or so.

That week or so turned into 320 days.

The wait almost seemed worth it when Crosby made that fabulous return against the Islanders. None of the Penguins were surprised when he played so well. He scored on his first shot, nearly blowing the lid off Consol Energy Center. He finished with two goals and two assists with eight shots on goal. Of course, the Penguins weren't surprised. They had watched Crosby practice for weeks, saw him blow by their defensemen every day with his incredible speed, marveled as he did things with the puck that no other human can do.

Many felt Crosby could have returned sooner. But they also realized he couldn't play again until he was right in his mind, until he believed he was 100 percent and could withstand anything on the ice. They were thrilled that day finally came against the Islanders.

Now, the Penguins -- like the rest of us -- have to wonder when that day will come again for Crosby.

"Sid knows his body better than anybody else," Bylsma said Monday. "He's not feeling 100 percent. He'll return to practice and playing when he is feeling 100 percent. That's where you go."

You think you're frustrated?

Imagine the frustration in the Penguins room.

Imagine Crosby's frustration.

"Frustrated doesn't even describe it," he said. "It's not fun watching."

This is for the lunatic fringe:

Forget that no one becomes the absolute best in any professional sport by being soft. Forget that Crosby led his team to a Stanley Cup championship and his country to an Olympic gold medal. Forget that he's the face of the NHL.

Once you understand how much hockey means to Crosby, you'll never say he's soft again.

I've never been around a player who loves his sport more.

Mario Lemieux had more hockey ability, but he never loved the game as much. He played it because he was great at it and made a fortune from it.

Crosby is making a fortune, too. No one is saying otherwise. A contract worth $8.7 million a year qualifies as a fortune.

But Crosby lives for hockey. The money just happens to be a bonus. I won't insult your intelligence by suggesting he would play for nothing -- no one would -- but I'll bet he would think twice about it.

Patience, people.

Crosby will play again.

It's nice to think it really will be worth the wait.

Ron Cook: rcook@post-gazette.com. Ron Cook can be heard on the "Vinnie and Cook" show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan. More articles by this author

Sidney Crosby and the 100-percent headache


Sidney Crosby and the 100-percent headache

Sidney Crosby told the media on Monday that his absence from the Pittsburgh Penguins lineup will extend for more than the two games the team said he'd miss last week.

In fact, he said there's "no timetable"; hearing those words from Crosby again is nightmarish.

Crosby said he did an ImPACT test that was "pretty good" and in no way comparable to the results he saw in January, when two blows to the head kept him out until November. As he said — and to which Chris Pronger and the Flyers can attest — those concussion tests aren't the be-all, end-all; symptoms and results can change with time.

Via the Penguins, Crosby said he's felt some post-concussion symptoms:
"I skated the following day after with exertion. I just didn't feel right. After talking with everyone I figured it was better to be cautious and not take any chances. That's where I'm at right now.

"I've been doing light exertion stuff and seeing how that goes. It's that whole (recovery) routine again, but hopefully not as long. When I wasn't doing something for 6, 7 months that process was a little longer. Hopefully, that's not the case here."
Crosby also confirmed that it wasn't the collision with Chris Kunitz that put him on the shelf. So the focus returns to the this hit by David Krecji of the Boston Bruins:



Crosby's threshold for a return to the lineup is feeling 100 percent.

Said Coach Dan Bylsma, via Josh Yohe of the Tribune Review:
"It's frustrating for Sid. Sid knows his body better than anyone else. He's not feeling 100 percent. He'll return when he is 100 [percent]."
Lambert was correct when he wrote that we all, for the most part, pushed away thoughts that this could happen again after Crosby lit up the NHL in his return. At the first sign of trouble, he was going to be out of the lineup again, and indefinitely.

Which leads to two uncomfortable questions: Will he ever feel 100 percent again, given that one knock to the head has knocked him out of the lineup; and if that's the case, what does it mean for his own expectations and/or the rest of his NHL career?

With the U.S. Hockey Hall of Fame inductions this week, Pat LaFontaine's name has come up a few times. If you haven't read it, Brainline.org has a harrowing look at his career of multiple concussions (.pdf). It lends insight to the competitive spirit vs. the injured brain; the frustration that accompanies concussion symptoms; and, perhaps most of all, how lucky a player like Sidney Crosby is to play in an era where concussion protocol and treatment is advanced and attentive where it was confused and ineffective during LaFontaine's days.

Said LaFontaine to the NY Times recently on Crosby:
"It's a tough thing to go through head injuries and concussions. The only silver lining is that your perspective on everything changes, and your appreciation level for the littlest things goes way up. I remember not knowing if I'd ever play again, and then going back and playing. I never appreciated the game so much. I reveled in everything — practice, trips, being on the ice, making plays, assisting, scoring, helping a team win. Everything meant so much, because it was taken away from you and you never knew if you were going to have a chance to do it at that level again."
Crosby had that all back for a moment. To have it in doubt again must be devastating.

From elation to gloom – the NHL spirals into another abyss

By Roy MacGregor
The Globe and Mail
http://www.theglobeandmail.com/sports/hockey/
December 13, 2011

PITTSBURGH, PA - FILE: Sidney Crosby #87 of the Pittsburgh Penguins waits to take a face off against the Boston Bruins on December 5, 2011 at CONSOL Energy Center in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. It was reported that Sidney Crosby of the Pittsburgh Penguins is out indefinitely with concussion-like symptoms after a recurrence of the problems that sidelined him for more than 10 months earlier this year December 12, 2011. (Photo by Jamie Sabau/Getty Images)

Perhaps it is just the season of peace and goodwill, but many hockey observers who were all over the NHL this year for its inaction on head shots and fist fights are today feeling just a bit sorry for hockey.

It is as if the Dark Ages have unexpectedly rolled back, the relief of only three weeks ago – when Sidney Crosby returned after 11 months of struggling with postconcussion syndrome to score four points against the New York Islanders – instantly turned to distant memory. Crosby has not scored a goal since his two that euphoric night of Nov. 21.

This past weekend, his Pittsburgh Penguins announced he would skip two road games as a precaution after “not feeling 100 per cent” following two slight on-ice collisions. Then, on Monday, Crosby failed to show at the Penguins’ morning practice. He later announced that he would not play in Tuesday’s game against the Detroit Red Wings. (The Penguins are also scheduled to play the Senators in Ottawa on Friday.) While Crosby called the setback beyond frustrating, he added that: “After talking with everyone, I figured it was better to be cautious and not take any chances. That’s where I’m at right now.”

What is curious about this turn of events is that here the NHL is blameless. Even if head shots had been eliminated and all fighting banned, this setback could not have been prevented. Teammates will always collide, accidental hits to the head are impossible to prevent.

The absence of hockey’s 24-year-old superstar has sucked the wind out of sails that billowed in late November when the native of Cole Harbour, N.S., returned with such fanfare. In the days following the Penguins’ 5-0 defeat of the Islanders, the hockey world was aTwitter with predictions that he might even win the NHL scoring race.

“Sidney Crosby’s back, guys,” linemate Pascal Dupuis said that night.

It turns out the announcement was premature.

In a bizarre coincidence, the current NHL scoring leader, 23-year-old Claude Giroux of Hearst, Ont., is also out after suffering an accidental hit to the head – delivered by a teammate’s knee – in a game against the Tampa Bay Lightning. Giroux will miss Tuesday’s game against the Washington Capitals. So, too, will Flyers captain Chris Pronger and rookie Brayden Schenn, both sidelined with concussion-like symptoms.

Last season’s rookie of the year, 19-year-old Jeff Skinner of the Carolina Hurricanes, is also out of action following a heavy hit during a match against the Edmonton Oilers. The team has not disclosed the nature of the injury suffered by the native of Markham, Ont.

But player injuries are not all the league has suffered through in recent days. An exhaustive New York Times investigation into the life and death of New York Rangers brain-damaged enforcer Derek Boogaard has taken an issue long familiar in Canadian media and given it new prominence in influential American circles.

As well, the rising concern over the long-term effects of taking shots to the head in a league that refuses to ban fighting took a blow itself this past week when a Canadian company, In The Game, produced a series of blood-spattered trading cards celebrating NHL fighters. One card, for former Toronto Maple Leafs enforcer Wade Belak, who died under mysterious circumstances last summer, “disgusts” Belak’s mother.

But nothing compares to the effect Crosby’s long-term concussion had on the game this year and the unknown effect that his problems may have in the future. Crosby is not only the face of the NHL but is beloved in Canada as the scorer of the goal that gave Canada the Olympic gold medal in Vancouver in February of 2010. Concerns for his health reverberate beyond the Pittsburgh team and beyond the league itself to the very roots of hockey, where minor-hockey parents are increasingly concerned about the effects of head hits on the health of their children.

With Crosby sitting out again, there is growing worry that his career path might follow that of Paul Kariya, a budding superstar whose potential greatness was snuffed by a series of concussions. When the 36-year-old Vancouver native finally retired from the game this year, he told The Globe and Mail’s Eric Duhatschek: “The thing that I worry about is that you’ll get a guy who is playing with a concussion, and he gets hit, and he dies at centre ice. Can you imagine would happen to the league if a guy dies at centre ice?”

Reeling again, the league is pinning its hopes for recovery on its Winter Classic outdoor match that in recent years has caused a rise in interest and American television ratings. This year’s match is set for Jan. 2 in Philadelphia, the Flyers playing host to the Rangers.

However, should Crosby not return by then, that much-trumpeted outdoor game will only serve to remind of the previous outdoor match, New Year’s Day 2011, when Crosby suffered the first hit to the head that would send the NHL into its dark spiral.

More related to this story

Monday, December 12, 2011

Run to prominence: Steelers Mike Wallace a big-play threat

By Scott Brown, PITTSBURGH TRIBUNE-REVIEW
http://www.pittsburghlive.com/x/pittsburghtrib/sports/?_s_icmp=nav_sports
Sunday, December 11, 2011

PITTSBURGH, PA - OCTOBER 16: Mike Wallace(notes) #17 of the Pittsburgh Steelers warms up prior to the game against the Jacksonville Jaguars on October 16, 2011 at Heinz Field in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. (Photo by Jared Wickerham/Getty Images)

A knock on the door led her to a youth football coach holding her injured son. For Sonjia Wallace, it also slammed shut a different door.

There would be no more football for her son, not after someone had stepped on his eye, leaving it swollen and in need of medical care.

It took several trips to the doctor to fix the eye. It also took years before Wallace allowed her son to play organized football again. When she finally relented, she told him, "OK, Michael, you can play, but you make sure you run. Don't let nobody catch you."

Mike Wallace has done his best to follow through on an impossible mandate from his nervous mother. And if his sublime speed gets the New Orleans native where he ultimately wants to go, that anecdote may well become part of Wallace's lore.

In his third NFL season, the Steelers receiver has established himself as one of the NFL's premier big-play threats.

Wallace on Thursday night eclipsed 1,000 yards receiving for the second consecutive season, and he already has a dozen 100-yard receiving games to his credit. Hall of Famer John Stallworth had 25 such games during a 14-year Steelers career.

Wallace has everyone's attention on the field. His blistering early-season pace has slowed -- he has gone six consecutive games without going over 100 yards receiving -- but the 6-foot, 199-pounder still has an outside shot at Yancey Thigpen's franchise record for receiving yards in a season (1,398 in 1997).

"I believe we're watching something special," said quarterback Byron Leftwich, who is on injured reserve with a broken arm but is still a regular presence at the Steelers' South Side headquarters. "I believe when all's said and done, he'll go down as one of the best ever from a numbers standpoint. People don't even call him one of the top 10 wide receivers in this league, but he's got a chance to have better numbers than a lot of people."

There are 10 players whose statistics Wallace checks regularly. They are the receivers taken ahead of him in the 2009 NFL Draft. That teams passed over him for more than two rounds stokes Wallace's inner embers.

Asked if he doesn't get his due, Wallace shrugged and smiled.

"I think we're public enemy No. 1. People want us to fail, but we're going to keep pushing," he said. "People don't have to tell us we're good. We know we're good. The world will find out eventually when we hold up that Lombardi (Trophy)."

Unearthing a gem

The assignment offered a chance for Randy Fichtner to return to Tennessee, where he had spent two coaching stints at Memphis.

But the opportunity to see family and old friends was not the only reason Fichtner embraced the idea of representing the Steelers at Memphis' Pro Day workout. Timing and proximity also allowed him to attend Pro Day at the University of Mississippi -- and get a firsthand look at Wallace, who had intrigued him at the NFL Scouting Combine by running a 4.28 in the 40-yard dash.

The Rebels were flush with NFL prospects, and their headliners were offensive tackle Michael Oher -- his story inspired the best-selling book and movie, "The Blind Side" -- and defensive tackle Peria Jerry.

As Fichtner took note of how many NFL coaches, general managers and scouts were at Ole Miss' Pro Day, something struck him: He was the only receivers coach.

The receivers attending the workout were such a low priority that there was no quarterback to throw to them. Fichtner ended up running drills for the wideouts, many of whom were from schools that did not have Pro Day workouts.

He also got a chance to put Wallace through a personal workout and interview him. He came away impressed with Wallace's ability to do more than just run.

"Believe me, I threw some bad passes, and it wasn't on purpose," said Fichtner, who is now the Steelers' quarterbacks coach, "and he was adjusting and catching."

When he returned to Pittsburgh, Fichtner looked up Wallace's college statistics. He noticed his production generally spiked late in seasons, something Fichtner chalked up to Wallace playing for different coaches and quarterbacks.

That was enough for the Steelers to put Wallace on "our radar," Fichtner said.

Not that Wallace had any idea they were interested. He had not interviewed with the Steelers at the combine or made a pre-draft visit to Pittsburgh. When the Steelers took Wallace with the 20th pick in the third round of the draft, 84th overall, it surprised him.

It moved his brother, Reggie, to tears.

"He said, 'Ma, do you realize that was my favorite team? And my little brother is going to play for them?' " Sonjia Wallace said.

For two brothers who had been separated by the streets of New Orleans, it provided a connection on which both still thrive.

Rising above

Reggie Wallace, the oldest of five kids, gave Mike the nickname "Rock" as a toddler because he never cried when he fell.

"He always had that love for his little brother and took care of his little brother," Sonjia Wallace said. "He definitely has a good heart. He just did some dumb things."

Reggie learned the Steelers drafted his brother while he was in a Louisiana state jail. He is serving time for selling drugs and is an example of what Wallace overcame while growing up in a West Bank neighborhood of New Orleans.

"He never really talked to me about street life. It was not something I wanted to do," said Wallace, who also lost a half-brother to street violence. "I can't buy my mom a house sitting on a corner selling drugs. I owe her everything."

Sonjia Wallace held down two jobs for about four years -- she worked as a presser at a dry cleaner and a caregiver at a home for mentally and physically challenged people -- and she sometimes only saw her children in the morning.

The sacrifices she made is why Wallace, who is in the final year of his rookie contract, plans to buy her a dream house.

Overcoming his environment shaped Wallace as much as a person as it did a player. That is something Steelers receivers coach Scottie Montgomery learned the more he got to know Wallace.

"If there's something to be done away from here with young kids, he's one of those people with an inner-city situation that understands that," said Montgomery, who is in his second season with the Steelers. "He knows his situation 10 years ago was completely different than it is now. I just didn't realize how much he cared about this opportunity. Now I know."

Not forgetting where he came from includes his brother and the unconditional love they share.

The two remain in regular contact -- they spoke last Sunday before Wallace scored two touchdowns against the Bengals -- and Wallace plans to bring Reggie to Pittsburgh after he is released from prison in 2013.

"He tells me words can't explain it how he's feeling, how good I'm making his time go," Wallace said. "It's never good in jail, but it makes it a lot of easier for him when I'm doing well."

'Extra gear' propels Wallace

Wallace may have world-class speed, but he is not a textbook sprinter.

His feet jut out slightly when he walks and runs -- think of them pointing to the 11 and 1 on a clock -- and his track coach at O. Perry Walker High School tried to change his style.

It didn't stick, and it didn't matter.

"That's just how I am," Wallace said. "Nobody could ever catch me."

Wallace's speed stands out on the football field.

"When he sees the ball in the air, he has that extra gear," Leftwich said. "Mike's like a center fielder, seeing the ball come off the bat. He's just running, and he'll find it later on to make a catch."

"Mike Wallace is an unbelievable talent," said Arizona Cardinals receiver Larry Fitzgerald, a perennial Pro Bowler. "Everybody knows what his skill set is, and he is still finding a way to get it done."

Wallace led all rookie receivers with 756 receiving yards in 2009. He had nearly 1,300 receiving yards last season, his first one as a starter. In between those seasons, Wallace's infamous "one-trick pony" nickname was born.

It happened during an offseason practice in 2010, while the Steelers were taking part in an 11-on-11 drill. As Wallace took his place at the line of scrimmage, free safety Ryan Clark called out, "Just stay back. He's a one-trick pony."

Steelers coach Mike Tomlin didn't run with the sobriquet; he galloped with it, using it as away to prod Wallace.

Not that Wallace needs extra motivation, especially as he is the link between the past and a better future for his family.

Wallace is supremely confident, though when he claims he can be the best in the game, he says it so matter of factly that it doesn't comes across as bluster.

That may be because in the next breath Wallace, who turned 25 in August, concedes there is still much for him to learn.

"I want to be one of the best ever," Wallace said. "I want people to remember me."

"He can be great," Montgomery said, "if he just allows it to happen."

Sunday, December 11, 2011

Harrison deserves hefty fine

By Ron Cook, Pittsburgh Post-Gazette
http://www.post-gazette.com/sports/
December 11, 2011


It's easy to predict the Steelers' week as they prepare to play a big game against the playoff-bound San Francisco 49ers Dec. 19 at Candlestick Park.

The NFL will review linebacker James Harrison's hit Thursday night on Cleveland Browns quarterback Colt McCoy, which resulted in a 15-yard personal foul penalty on Harrison for helmet-to-helmet contact. The league will fine Harrison heavily, perhaps even suspend him considering his history of similar hits. The Steelers will scream NFL commissioner Roger Goodell is out to get them and is especially targeting Harrison. Harrison will smolder and say he was wronged, although he will stop short of calling Goodell a "crook," a "devil" and a gay slur, as he did in a magazine article in the summer. The team will move on and take out all of the anger on the 49ers.

Sound about right?

There is no way Harrison avoids a stiff fine. There is no way he should. His hit on McCoy in the Steelers' 14-3 win is exactly the hit the NFL wants to take out of the game. It was much worse than safety Ryan Clark's hit on Baltimore Ravens tight end Ed Dickson Nov. 6. That hit resulted in a $40,000 fine for Clark and prompted outrage from everyone in the Steelers organization from coach Mike Tomlin, who called the fine "excessive," to the players, who went on another rant about Goodell and his unlimited disciplinary power even though their union signed off on it in the new Collective Bargaining Agreement.

A $50,000 fine for Harrison, perhaps?

Maybe $75,000?

It seems unlikely that Harrison will be suspended. Nor should he be. This was his first personal foul this season. He has done a much better job playing by the rules, yet has managed to keep his image as the NFL's most ferocious player.

But that's just one man's view. A lot of national media are calling for the NFL to come down hard on Harrison. They point to the $100,000 he was fined last season for four different hits. They say he still hasn't learned the difference between a legal hit and one that can knock a player into next week.

It's not hard to imagine the terror McCoy felt when he saw Harrison coming. He had just scrambled to his left and dumped a short pass to running back Montario Hardesty midway through the fourth quarter. McCoy had to know he was going to take a brutal hit because he had just released the ball. Harrison certainly didn't get to him late. But McCoy was right to have the reasonable expectation that he wouldn't take a vicious shot in the facemask from the crown of Harrison's helmet.

It's amazing that McCoy got up, let alone made it to the Cleveland sideline. It's beyond comprehension that Browns coach Pat Shurmur and the team's medical staff allowed him to return to the game after three plays. At least it was incomprehensible to McCoy's father, Brad, a longtime high school coach, who ripped the decision to put his son back in. The team acknowledged Friday that Colt McCoy had a concussion but said he didn't show symptoms until after the game.

"He was basically out [cold] after the hit," Brad McCoy told The Plain Dealer of Cleveland.

Colt McCoy said after the game that he didn't remember the hit.

NFL officials need to look into that when they review the Harrison hit.

But, really, the Browns aren't on trial here, are they? Nor is Cleveland defensive tackle Phil Taylor, who was penalized in the first quarter for delivering a blow to Steelers quarterback Ben Roethlisberger's head and surely will be fined. Nor is Steelers linebacker James Farrior, who will be fined for the second time this season for hitting McCoy out of bounds in the third quarter.

No, this is about Harrison.

Everyone will be watching to see how Goodell and his people handle the Harrison hit.

"I hate him and will never respect him," Harrison said of Goodell in a Men's Journal article in July in which he also used the derogatory terms to describe him.

Harrison later apologized, calling his comments "inappropriate at least and way out of line."

The league office took no action against Harrison, presumably because the article came out during the NFL lockout.

Harrison will not -- should not -- escape this time.

Ron Cook: rcook@post-gazette.com. Ron Cook can be heard on the "Vinnie and Cook" show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan. More articles by this author